The Universal Declaration: The Preamble, the Proclamation and the Prime Directive by Christopher Sherwood


Course: Grade 12 Global Issues

Teaching aids:

References:

Objective: By using the immensely popular television/movie series Star Trek created by Gene Roddenbury as an enrichment tool, and its "Prime Directive" which governs all interaction between the fictional United Federation of planets and other intergalactic civilizations, the class will better understand the purpose of the United Nation's Universal Declaration's Preamble and Proclamation for human dignity and equality.

Introduction: Have the class pre-read the Prime Directive, the Preamble and the Proclamation of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Provide a two column print out of both documents to the class for comparison purposes. Have the class comment on the document's similarities and differences.

The teacher should ask the following types of questions to initiate a discussion of the reasons for why these types of documents are devised:

If possible, the teacher should attempt to procure a copy of the "Patterns of Force" episode from the second season of Star Trek to review in class. If this is not possible a plot summary of the episode can be provided for student use.

Presentation: The teacher should proceed to review the various sections of the Preamble to the Universal Declaration and draw attention to similar aspects of the Prime Directive such as:

The need to establish equal and inalienable rights to all members of humanity (and supposedly other worlds who also honor these same values) as the foundations of not only freedom, peace, and justice in our world, (but of all worlds and galaxies). The need to promote the development of friendly relations between nations(and worlds!)

Several contrasts in the Prime Directive should be noted as well, including the fact that Star Fleet is a dedicated force that will preserve, protect, and enforce the Prime Directive and that all members are equal under the directive (no veto power!) Etc. This might be compared to the UN Security Council and the veto power of certain nations in the UN Charter.

Review: Review and discuss the reasons why such documents are designed and for whom they are designed to serve. Ask the class if the rights as guaranteed in the Universal Declaration are indeed "universally" observed? Ask how this might be monitored and enforced. Discuss the concept of rights and responsibilities that go with them.

Questions/Assignments/Activities:

1. Does the Prime Directive reflect the influence of the Universal Declaration?

2. Compare and contrast the Declaration's preamble and proclamation with the Prime Directive.

3. When was the original episode of Star Trek aired? When was the Declaration and the ensuing Covenants and Protocols signed? What was the political climate of the time on Earth?

4. Discuss the meaning of "self - determination" from both the Prime Directive and the Universal Declaration perspective.

5. Using the Internet address resource above, review the episodes from the first three Star trek seasons. Are any of the episodes directly related to human or civil rights issues taking place on earth at that time? List them.

6. If possible show the class the episode, "Patterns of Force" from season two. (See attached episode summary) A class discussion could include the following discussion topics:

Closure: Further episodes of Star trek could be examined using similar human rights issues. Many episodes from the first three seasons constitute social commentary on issues such as racial bias, discrimination, inequality, as well as armed conflict and aggression.

 

The Prime Directive of the United Federation of Planets

"Insofar as we, the members of the United Federation of Planets, do recognize and respect the vital role that each and all our separate peoples have played in the building of our union, and insofar as that union is then the product of our differences as well as our commonalities, one built as much of the acknowledgment of our failing as the recognition of our potentials, we so do resolve, as a United Federation of individual Planets strong both in spirit and the desire to live free, never to lose sight of those principles which by fate or providence, have served to establish this Federation as a meeting of equals.

We shall foster within the bounds our common influence the inescapable belief that all life is possessed of the inalienable right to flourish on its own terms and its own time and place.

Therefore, we devote our energies to the establishment and fostering of such state in equal measure throughout the Known Galaxy, and dedicate our Star Fleet to the preservation and protection of that state; that state being an insular program of non-interaction and non-interference with those cultures whose development of self and whose singular right to self determination would be unduly burdened or damaged by the interaction with, or even the knowledge of, more technologically advanced races, even those whose motives and intentions are unimpeachable and altruistic, even unto the destruction of the culture by lack of action, it being none the more justifiable to crush the special essence of a new culture in the process of saving it.

We shall do all within our power to leave the development of any and all cultures to their own devices, to let them flourish or fail as their differing gifts allow, and to prevent any and all who would deprive them of this, the most basic right, from performing self-serving and selfish actions at the expense of the innocents, until such time as they, themselves, come forward, as equals, and mindful of their place within the greater whole.

We stand unified in our avowed proclamation of this as first and foremost principle, our PRIME DIRECTIVE".

Star Trek Plot Summaries - "Patterns of Force"

When the Enterprise approaches the inner planet Ecos to investigate the cessation of communication with researcher John Gill, it is attacked with a rocket carrying a nuclear weapon.

This is puzzling as well as dangerous, since neither the outer planet Zeon nor the inner planet Ecos is technologically advanced enough to possess rockets or nuclear warheads. The Enterprise retreats to maximum orbital distance and Kirk and Spock beam down (after having position-broadcasting transponders surgically implanted in the case of mishaps).

Kirk and Spock discover that a Nazi movement has swept the planet, complete with genocide of the "Zeon Pigs" residing on Ecos. They view a public newscast in which the Iron Cross second class is presented to Daras, hero of the Fatherland. Kirk and Spock are also shocked to learn that Gill appears to be the leader of the planet's Nazi movement. When they are approached and questioned by a Nazi Lieutenant, they overpower him and Spock steals his uniform. Spock then pretends that Kirk is a Zeon he has captured and nerve pinches a Gestapo commander who wishes to take charge of Kirk. This provides Kirk's uniform, and Spock compliments Kirk by telling him "You should make a very convincing Nazi".

As Kirk and Spock make their way to see the Fuhrer, they are confronted by a Nazi S.S. Major after Spock neglects to salute him. The Major becomes suspicious and Spock is exposed when he is forced to remove his helmet. Spock and Kirk are whipped in the process of being interrogated. Nazi Party Chairman Eneg interrupts the "questioning" and tells the Nazis to lock up Spock and Kirk for an hour (in contradiction to standing orders to execute prisoners after interrogation).

In prison, Kirk and Spock speak to an imprisoned Zeon (whom they have previously encountered being beaten on the streets by the Nazis) and find that the Nazi movement began several years ago (corresponding with the arrival of Gill).

They escape from prison by making a primitive laser from the rubidium crystals in their transponders using their cell's incandescent bulb as the excitation source (not quite a flash arc and ruby crystal, but close enough in a pinch). Spock hides outside the cell and then nerve pinches the guard when Kirk summons him under the pretext of wanting to talk. Kirk and Spock also allow the Zeon prisoner to tag along.

Kirk and Spock penetrate Nazi headquarters with the help of secretary Damas and Chairman Eneg. They discover that Gill is only the drugged puppet of Fuhrer Melakon after he gives a stilted speech unleashing the final assault on Zeon, McCoy is beamed down and manages to barely overcome the drug. Gill tells them that he started the Nazi movement to unify the planet (because it was the "most efficient system Earth ever knew"). With an extra hypo from Kirk, Gill manages to call back the invasion fleet and denounce Melakon as a traitor. Melakon grabs a machine gun and kills Gill, only to be shot himself. Chairman Eneg takes over and stops the killing, declaring that "it is time to live the way our Fuhrer intended." Kirk and company then return to the Enterprise in peace.